Bluegrass

Don’t count your chickens before your eggs have hatched

by | Jun 20, 2019 | Opinion

To read some of the alarmist headlines pointing to the latest polls, you might conclude that the 2020 election is already over and President Donald Trump has been ousted.

After all, the latest Fox News poll shows former Vice President Joe Biden ahead of Trump, 49 percent to 39 percent, and Sen. Bernie Sanders similarly leads Trump, 49 percent to 40 percent.

When you take out supposed undecideds or non-responses, that takes Biden up to 56 percent of the vote and Sanders to 55 percent, with Trump at 44 percent and 45 percent, respectively, a modern day rout.

But does anyone really expect such a lop-sided outcome come Nov. 2020? The largest landslide in recent history was 2008, but even with the economy completely collapsed and Democrats on their way to winning a filibuster-proof majority in the Senate, the worst possible conditions for Republicans on the ballot, Barack Obama only garnered 52.9 percent of the popular vote.

That is not to say that Biden or Sanders could not defeat Trump, but by 10 points or 9 points? It seems not only unlikely, but exceedingly improbable.

The news came amid separate reports that the Trump campaign has fired its internal pollster after results leaked to NBC News, which stated, “In Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, Florida and Michigan — three states where Trump edged Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton by narrow margins that proved decisive in his victory — Trump trails Biden by double-digits… He’s also behind the former vice president in Iowa by 7 points, in North Carolina by 8 points, in Virginia by 17 points, in Ohio by 1 point, in Georgia by 6 points… In Texas, where a Democratic presidential nominee hasn’t won since President Jimmy Carter in 1976, Trump leads by just 2 points.”

For starters, polls 17 months out from an election may not be reliable. They do not take into account unknown quantities, such as voters feeling the same about Biden or Sanders now versus when they find out more about the candidate during the course of a competitive campaign. Or third party candidates. Or how the economy might be doing. Or who will end up doing well in the Democratic primaries, and what it will mean for their election chances. These are all very important, if not determinative factors in re-election cycles, and they’re not even on the table yet.

Looking back at the same point in the cycle, a May 2015 Quinnipiac poll confidently suggested that Hillary Clinton would beat Donald Trump in a hypothetical matchup, 50 percent to 32 percent. When undecideds or non-responses are removed, it comes out 61 percent to 39 percent.

A June 2015 Fox News poll had Clinton at 52 percent and Trump at 34 percent, or 60 percent to 40 percent with undecideds and non-responses removed.

As far as the state-by-state contests are concerned, it is worth noting that Nate Silver’s Fivethirtyeight.com model looks at state-by-state polling and found that Hillary Clinton would most certainly win the election, with a 70 percent probability on the Nov. 8, 2016. Clinton was supposed to receive 300 Electoral College votes and win the election.

None of it turned out to be true. Trump won the Electoral College in 2016, not Clinton, 304 to 227, in spite of the state-by-state polls and head-to-head matchup polls. As for the popular vote, Clinton received 48.2 percent, and Trump 46.1 percent. Given Clinton’s favored status in the polls, it was one of the greatest upsets in American political history and helps explain much of the shock on the left that followed the election.

On Twitter, Trump suggested on June 17 that “Polls are always bad for me.” He is not wrong.

Trump got elected with a favorable rating of only about 40 percent and unfavorable of almost 60 percent. It is also worth noting at this point in both the Reagan and Obama presidencies, both were upside down on job approval.

In fact, Trump under-polled what his actual favorability number was in 2016 and the current polling may be doing the same thing just be serving as a proxy for job approval and under sampling Trump supporters, or alternately, Trump supporters being reluctant to respond to polls.

Granted, other pollsters were far more accurate in their readings of the electorate. Rasmussen Reports springs to mind, which had the most accurate polls down the stretch to reality on the ground.

Which, by the way, is a giant grain of salt for Democrats. The most recent job approval from Rasmussen shows Trump at 48 percent.

When you break it down, President Trump is in a far more commanding position than the early polls suggest at the moment, which are almost assuredly wrong about the state of the race. So, watch for national polls to tighten naturally as we approach 2020 and the actual primary contests to follow, and then tighten even more once Democrats determine their eventual nominee. Happens every time.

What was that about counting chickens?

By Robert Romano the Vice President of Public Policy at Americans for Limited Government.

For more opinion pieces like this subscribe in print or online.

Collin FP Summer/Fall 2026 registration

0 Comments

FISD Grad

Related News

To the letter

To the letter

Columnist John Moore still writes letters. His latest went to his mom while she was on vacation. Photo: John Moore By John Moore | TheCountryWriter.com When I was about 10, I wrote a letter to my aunt, who lived in Oklahoma. I’d never written a letter to...

read more
Have you no couth?

Have you no couth?

Columnist John Moore still isn’t allowed to use the good towels. His is behind the bathroom door. Photo: John Moore As a kid, I was fairly certain I’d never get any couth. I wasn’t sure what couth was, but it seemed to be important to my grandparents. If you made a...

read more
Glad you’re here

Glad you’re here

Columnist John Moore is offering to teach anyone who's visiting the US how to eat biscuits and gravy. Photo John Moore By John Moore | TheCountryWriter.com I’m not much on soccer, but it seems the rest of the world is. As I write this, America is covered up...

read more
Summer of ‘76

Summer of ‘76

Columnist John Moore still has and uses the radio that kept him, his cousin, and best friend company during the summer of the 1976 American Bicentennial celebrations. Photo John Moore By John Moore | TheCountryWriter.com Author’s note: This week’s column was...

read more
Raising the steaks

Raising the steaks

Columnist John Moore's great grandfather, Thornton Parmer Moore, is pictured circa 1935 in his blacksmith shop. Like most of the era, he made just about everything he needed. Photo John Moore By John Moore | TheCountryWriter.com As a kid, I often heard the...

read more
In the cards

In the cards

Columnist John Moore spent most Saturday nights of his childhood watching the adults play cards and drink lots of coffee. Photo John Moore By John Moore | TheCountryWriter.com In 868 A.D., according to Chinese historical records, a princess was said to have...

read more
Who’ll stop the rain

Who’ll stop the rain

Columnist John Moore wonders if we can stop the rain we started. Photo John Moore By John Moore | TheCountryWriter.com Back in 2011, it didn’t rain. It didn’t rain for a long, long time. It didn’t rain for so long that fires began to pop up where I live. One...

read more
State’s wind projects at a standstill

State’s wind projects at a standstill

Dozens of Texas wind projects have been halted because the Department of Defense has not approved the federal permits required for them to move forward, the Austin American-Statesman reported. Data from the American Clean Power Association indicate that the state...

read more
Rockin’ down the highway

Rockin’ down the highway

Columnist John Moore has played guitar since he was eight. The Doobie Brothers helped remind him of why he still plays. Photo John Moore When I first picked up a guitar in 1970, my fingers didn’t make the sounds I wanted to hear. But I knew that if I kept trying, I...

read more
Listen here

Listen here

Columnist John Moore has a book on communication his wife bought him in the early 90s. He intends to read it soon. In the early 90s, there was a self-help, relationship book called, “Men Are From Mars, Women Are From Venus.” The goal of publishing this was for the...

read more
Subscribe 300x250 - Love