Bluegrass

Opinion: Pricing proposal gives patients a fair shake

by | May 30, 2019 | Opinion

Drug company CEOs recently ventured to Capitol Hill to testify before the Senate Finance Committee.

The executives got an earful from lawmakers, who are rightly concerned about drug spending. Senators are under pressure from voters, 80 percent of whom say “taking action to lower prescription drug prices” should be one of Congress’s top priorities this year.

To this end, the Trump administration recently proposed a rule that could save patients billions at the pharmacy. The rule would make it easier for Americans suffering from chronic diseases to afford needed medications. The reform could even drive down national healthcare spending.

The rule targets pharmacy benefit managers. Insurance companies hire these middlemen to administer prescription plans and negotiate with drug companies for discounts. Manufacturers offer discounts in exchange for PBMs agreeing to include drugs on “formularies,” the lists of medications that insurance plans cover.

The discounts secured by PBMs are substantial. Total discounts and rebates offered by drug companies ballooned to $150 billion in 2017. These discounts amount to roughly one-third of a drug’s list price.

If drug companies are offering ever-larger discounts, why do medicines seem to be getting more expensive for patients? It’s because insurers and PBMs keep these discounts to reduce premiums.

The lower premiums are nice, of course. But they provide minimal help to those who rely on medications and face high out-of-pocket costs.

For instance, a drug might have a list price of $300, but the insurer might acquire it for just $150 after rebates.

However, insurers don’t calculate coinsurance based on the negotiated price. If patients face 20-percent coinsurance, they’ll have to pay $60 every time they refill their prescriptions. If patients could pay coinsurance based on the discounted price, they’d pay just $30.

That $30 difference adds up for patients who take multiple drugs to manage their chronic diseases.

The Trump administration’s proposed rule would end this. It would prohibit PBMs from collecting rebates or discounts for medicines sold through Medicaid or Medicare Part D. Discounts and rebates would only be permitted if they were passed to patients at the pharmacy.

The reform would make it easier for America’s sickest patients to afford their medications. That could drive down overall healthcare spending.

Here’s why. Patients struggle to follow their treatment regimens when they face high out-of-pocket costs. When drug copays double, adherence falls by as much as 45 percent.

Non-adherence, a factor in 10 percent of all hospitalizations, costs our healthcare system between $100 billion and $289 billion each year.

Reducing out-of-pocket costs would improve medication adherence, thereby helping prevent needless suffering while saving our country billions.

Right now, the sickest patients pay a disproportionately high share of drug costs. The administration’s proposal would reduce out-of-pocket spending, helping more Americans afford the prescriptions they need to stay healthy.

 

By Kenneth E. Thorpe, professor of health policy at Emory University and chairman of the Partnership to Fight Chronic Disease.

Collin FP Summer/Fall 2026 registration

0 Comments

FISD Grad

Related News

Raising the steaks

Raising the steaks

Columnist John Moore's great grandfather, Thornton Parmer Moore, is pictured circa 1935 in his blacksmith shop. Like most of the era, he made just about everything he needed. Photo John Moore By John Moore | TheCountryWriter.com As a kid, I often heard the...

read more
In the cards

In the cards

Columnist John Moore spent most Saturday nights of his childhood watching the adults play cards and drink lots of coffee. Photo John Moore By John Moore | TheCountryWriter.com In 868 A.D., according to Chinese historical records, a princess was said to have...

read more
Who’ll stop the rain

Who’ll stop the rain

Columnist John Moore wonders if we can stop the rain we started. Photo John Moore By John Moore | TheCountryWriter.com Back in 2011, it didn’t rain. It didn’t rain for a long, long time. It didn’t rain for so long that fires began to pop up where I live. One...

read more
State’s wind projects at a standstill

State’s wind projects at a standstill

Dozens of Texas wind projects have been halted because the Department of Defense has not approved the federal permits required for them to move forward, the Austin American-Statesman reported. Data from the American Clean Power Association indicate that the state...

read more
Rockin’ down the highway

Rockin’ down the highway

Columnist John Moore has played guitar since he was eight. The Doobie Brothers helped remind him of why he still plays. Photo John Moore When I first picked up a guitar in 1970, my fingers didn’t make the sounds I wanted to hear. But I knew that if I kept trying, I...

read more
Listen here

Listen here

Columnist John Moore has a book on communication his wife bought him in the early 90s. He intends to read it soon. In the early 90s, there was a self-help, relationship book called, “Men Are From Mars, Women Are From Venus.” The goal of publishing this was for the...

read more
That whatchamacallit

That whatchamacallit

Columnist John Moore speaks Southern. He learned it in his grandfather's blacksmith shop. Photo John Moore Southern folks don’t need proper nouns. We have whatchamacallits and thingamajigs. My grandfather had the only blacksmith shop in Ashdown, Arkansas. That’s where...

read more
Berry berry good

Berry berry good

Columnist John Moore picks blackberries each spring. Something he’s done for a very long time. Photo: John Moore There wasn’t anything accidental about blackberry season in our family. When harvest time came, dad had the harvest trip mapped out long before the berries...

read more
Sounding off

Sounding off

Columnist John Moore still listens to the albums he bought over 50 years ago. Photo John Moore New music coming out used to be an event. Most of the time, you and your friends knew it was coming and you were waiting, money-in-hand, at the record shop to buy it. I...

read more
Hanging out

Hanging out

Columnist John Moore has endured many difficulties, but nothing's worse than wallpaper. Photo by John Moore There are two true tests for how solid your marriage is — COVID-19 and hanging wallpaper together. As I awoke from 9½ hours of sleep, all rested and ready for...

read more
Subscribe 300x250 - Love